When I was looking for PS2 controllers on Amazon, I saw this at the top and was immediately suspect of it. New? Only 3 ratings? And they are ALL 5/5? Seemed fishy! Boy was I wrong. These came in the mail and when I tested them out, WOW! Crisp buttons, VERY nice joysticks, and a quality build and finish. I was only going to order 2 to replace the nasty PS2 controllers from when I was a kid, but I ended up buying another 2 so me and my brother and his friends could all play Gauntlet Dark Legacy together!
TL;DR, if you are looking for third party PS2 controllers, buy these!